Amy Cole-McGuire played softball from 1990 to 1994. During that span, she was a four-time All-Mid-Ohio Conference selection and four-time NAIA All-District honoree. McGuire had a career fielding percentage of .924 at the shortstop position. She had a career batting average of .333. In addition to softball, McGuire played basketball for two seasons. She was inducted into the Hall of Fame with the Inaugural Class in 2000. McGuire is currently an assistant coach with the Shawnee State softball team.