Brandy Orsborne-Fyffe played softball from 1998 to 2001. During her career, she accumulated a batting average of .369, with 109 runs and 94 RBI. In the circle, she compiled a 10-3 record with a 3.42 ERA. In her senior season, Orsborne-Fyffe was named Conference Player of the Year and a second-team NAIA All-American. Orsborne-Fyffe was a three-time all-conference selection. She was an NAIA Scholar-Athlete and Conference Scholar-Athlete twice. She was inducted in 2011.