Crystal Pickelsimer played softball from 1997-2000. She was a four-time All-American Mideast Conference honoree and earned NAIA All-American honors as a junior and senior. Pickelsimer was the American Mideast Conference Player of the Year in 2000. She had a career-batting average of .431. Her 65 doubles and 18 triples were school records at the time of her graduation. She also broke the school record for doubles in a season (22) and walks in a career (78). Pickelsimer was inducted in 2006.