NAIA Hall of Fame
Kim White

NAIA Player of the Year
1997: Kim White

NAIA All-Americans
2001: Brandy Orsborne (second team)
2000: Crystal Pickelsimer (second team)
1999: Crystal Pickelsimer (first team)
1998: Kari Koehn (first team)
1997: Kari Koehn (first team), Kim White (first team)
1996: Kim White
1995: Kim White
1994: Kim White

MSC Coach of the Year
2012: Ralph Cole

MSC Freshman of the Year
2011: Kirsti Yates

MSC All-Conference Team
2013: Allie Chapman (first team), Holly Brabson (second team), Hannah Dittoe (second team), Ericka Leighty (second team), Ali Thompson (second team), Kirsti Yates (second team)
2012: Katy Bender (first team), Ali Thompson (first team), Kirsti Yates (first team), Ericka Leighty (second team)
2011: Kirsti Yates (first team), Sam Attinger (honorable mention), Abbey Barrett (honorable mention), Ericka Leighty (honorable mention), Ali Thompson (honorable mention)

AMC Coach of the Year
2012: Ralph Cole
1996: Ralph Cole
1995: Ralph Cole
1994: Ralph Cole
1993: Ralph Cole
1992: Ralph Cole

AMC Player of the Year
2001: Brandy Orsborne
2000: Crystal Pickelsimer
1997: Kim White
1996: Kim White
1995: Kim White
1994: Kim White

AMC Pitcher of the Year
2007: Lori Harmon

AMC Freshman of the Year
2006: Lori Harmon

AMC All-Conference Team
2010: Abbey Barrett (first team), Katie Daniel (first team), Ericka Leighty (second team), Ali Thompson (second team), Brooke Baker (honorable mention), Jazel DeAutremont (honorable mention)
2009: Emily Fuhrmann (second team), Ashley Speas (second team), Cassie Erlenwein (honorable mention), Lori Harmon (honorable mention)
2008: Lauren Ellis (first team), Emily Fuhrmann (first team), Lori Harmon (first team), Katie Wade (first team), Katie Daniel (second team), Tammie Jo Coleman (honorable mention)
2007: Lori Harmon (first team), Ashley Keen (first team), Ashley Adkins (second team), Emily Fuhrmann (second team), Tammie Jo Coleman (honorable mention), Ali Hull (honorable mention)
2006: Ashley Adkins (first team), Emily Fuhrmann (first team), Lori Harmon (first team), Tammie Jo Coleman (second team), Katie Wade (second team), Ali Hull (honorable mention)
2005: Britney Bayless (first team), Kristi Barka (second team), Rhonda Sacks (second team), Katie Wade (honorable mention), Tara Walker (honorable mention)
2003: Keri Bennett (honorable mention), Katie Gunnoe (honorable mention), Nikki Moore (honorable mention), Rhonda Sacks (honorable mention), Sarah Streeter (honorable mention)
2002: Carrie Kyne (first team), Kristie Coleman (honorable mention), Megan Felts (honorable mention)
2001: Erica Brickey (first team), Brandy Orsborne (first team), Kristen Grahmam (honorable mention), Carrie Kyne (honorable mention), Ashley Rawson (honorable mention)
2000: Crystal Pickelsimer (first team), Mindy Wolever (first team), Rachel Chandler (honorable mention), Brandy Orsborne (Honorable Mention)
1999: Jackie Hawk (first team), Crystal Pickelsimer (first team), Jessica Moore (second team), Brandy Orsborne (second team), Becky Holden (honorable mention)
1998: Kari Koehn (first team), Crystal Pickelsimer (first team)
1997: Leah Fickel (first team), Kari Koehn (first team), Crystal Pickelsimer (first team), Kim White (first team), Missy Lawson (second team)
1996: Marie Chapman (first team), Amy Evans (first team), Tiffany Moore (first team), Brandi Rose (first team), Renee Walls (first team), Kim White (first team), Leah Fickel (second team), Kari Koehn (second team), Missy Lawson (second team), Keri Davidson (honorable mention)
1995: Renee Walls (first team), Kim White (first team)
1994: Brandi Rose (first team), Jill Walters (first team), Kim White (first team)

AMC All-Conference Freshman Team
2010: Abbey Barrett
2006: Lori Harmon
2005: Katie Wade

NAIA Scholar Athletes
2012: Ericka Leighty, Ali Thompson
2010: Katie Daniel
2009: Katie Daniel, Lori Harmon
2008: Lori Harmon, Ali Hull-Keeton
2005: Rhonda Sacks
2003: Keri Bennett
2001: Brandy Orsborne
2000: Brandy Orsborne
1997: Marie Chapman, Jessica Hardy, Kari Koehn
1996: Leah Fickell, Tiffany Shanks-Moore
1994: Judy Shupert

MSC Scholar Athletes 
2013: Allie Chapman, Brytan Givens, Kelsey Jenkins, Ericka Leighty, Ali Thompson
2012: Allie Chapman, Ericka Leighty, Nikki Nance, Ali Thompson, Kirsti Yates
2011: Jazel DeAutremont, Ericka Leighty, Ali Thompson